An Experiment in Wet Felting – Felt Geodes

Last weekend I finally had a go at the craft of wet felting. It was not all sunshine and rainbows, some of my initial attempts would have made the front page of Pinterest Fail, but with a little persistence, I managed to make a few felt geodes and learnt a lot in the process.

wet felting geodes

This post is not so much a ‘how to’, but more of a ‘how I did, and what happened when’. Just because I’m craft inclined doesn’t mean that every attempt at a project turns out perfectly first time around. I thought you’d appreciate seeing some of my not so successful projects amongst all the fabbo ones.

So here’s how it went down:
I thought it would be fun to start off making felt balls with Emma but unfortunately those pesky balls just weren’t forming and Emma started to get upset, she lost it about 5 minutes in and went to watch TV leaving me with a bowlful of soapy water and something to prove.

felt ball fail

First attempt at making wet felted balls – no bueno!

I thought I was doing it right, hot soapy water, squish the felt in your hands and ‘Voilà!’ But no voilà, not even a little. I was getting really stressed out, there was a lot of cursing too.

I turned to google – Question “Wet Felting, what am I going wrong?” and found this video which really helped.

Mistake number 1 – not soaking the felt enough to ensure it was thoroughly saturated.

Mistake number 2 – being way too aggressive and pulling the fibres apart before they have had a chance to really mesh. The lady in the video describes handling the felt like you are holding a baby bunny.

Mistake number 3 – not using enough soap – you really need to go for it with the soap.

wet felting a ball - trouble shooting

Finally my attempts are paying off

I tried again, and with a little more practice and a gentler touch, the felt was finally coming together. I thought I’d try making a geode ball with multiple layers of felt, it took several hours but I managed to get something felted properly (or so I’d thought).


Once felt ball is holding together, I rolled it on a textured mesh to further assist in the felting process.

Unlike a tutorial I found that recommends all felt colours be wrapped when dry and then felted in one go, I worked on each layer at a time.

felt geode balls

Coloured inner sections of geodes ready to cover in white then grey wool fibre.

The one layer at a time didn’t work so well because even though each layer was fairly well felted, the layers didn’t bond to each other resulting in lamination. Once the geodes were cut, each colour separated from each other.

felt geode fail

On the upside, now I know how to make a felt bowl.

So after about 3 hours with my hands in soapy water, they were looking a bit pruney. I put on gloves about half way through but it was difficult to feel the fibre through the gloves and water got in anyway. Maybe an elastic band around the top of the glove would help.

wet felting is hard on hands

My hands got quite waterlogged after a few hours of wet felting.

I made three felt geodes in total and couldn’t wait for them to dry out so I could cut into them. They took about 24 hours to dry fully on the heater vent.

felt rocks

And after a bit of heavy duty cutting with some sharp scissors, the surprise was revealed.

felt geodes

I love how the colour gradation turned out but was a little disappointed that some of the layers were only just barely holding together. I couldn’t help myself and had to do some needle felting to really make the felt nice and solid.

needle felting

Here’s a before and after of the needle felting. You can see on the before the edges of the colours were much crisper, but unfortunately the felt geodes were falling apart. After, the needle felting the felt was denser and was one solid piece, but some of the colour definition was lost.

needle felt geode, before and after

Left – Before (only wet felting), Right – After (with needle felting)


Needle felted to stabilise the shape


Comparison of pre and post needle felted geodes.

So now what to do with these hemispheres of felt. Well they make good, and very pretty, pincushions in a suitable receptacle.

wet felted pincushion

So what’s my verdict on Wet Felting?

Did I enjoy it? Not initially, but I can see the appeal, and as my technique improved it was quite satisfying feeling the felt come together.

Will I try it again? Yes, I’d like to have a go at making a flat object or a bowl. I’ve had enough of balls for the moment.

Needle felting or wet felting? I still prefer the control of needle felting and it’s much gentler on my poor hands, but the surprise aspect of wet felting is entertaining.

What about the mess? Yes there was A LOT of water, everywhere. Maybe best done outside next time.

wet felted geodes

I’m interested in exploring how I can combine the technique of wet felting with some of the other things I do. I’ll keep you posted on my progress.

Now tell me, what do you think of my felt geodes?


  • Kate Lloyd says:

    I think you did a wonderful job. I’d love to give it a go one day, but it does seem quite challenging. Thanks for including the tips.

  • Elizabeth says:

    Those geodes are lovely!

    I had to give up wet felting for a while until I stopped using nasty dish soap. My poor skin is allergic to sulfates, especially Sodium Lauryl Sulfate.

    I switched to homemade olive oil soap and all is well. Try using natural soap- even bar soap. Shred it and add to water. Seriously. Decent soap made a world of difference for me.

    I like starting with a small amount of soap and water, then increasing pressure and liquid. My words area baby bird until you feel a crust.

    Your work is beautiful.

    • Thanks so much for the tips. I must admit I haven’t tried it again as it wasn’t very satisfying on first attempts, but I may revisit soon as the weather is cooling down which makes it perfect for felt craft.

    • Mel says:

      You could also use some panty hose next time to hold all the layers together, and if you haven’t felted a soap with your daughter you should, very fun, you can be rougher and try rubbing on different surfaces (bubble wrap, sushi mat)

  • Amanda says:

    Hi! I’m looking at doing wet felting geodes with my Girl Scout troop. How much wool do you think I should buy?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.